From Andrew Z, who posted this question at the end of last week:
"I have a question for everyone, and try to be as honest as possible. Do you consider this season a success if the Lakers just make the playoffs? Do they have to win a series? Does the late season progress of Luke, LO, and Kwame make this year a success? If you would have told me at the beginning of the year we would have this amount of wins, be in the playoffs, and those three guys would be playing at their current level, I would have asked "where do I sign up?" Just wondering if you all feel the same."
While some of you have already answered, AK and I thought it was a good question and didn't want it to get lost in the comments. Now that the Lakers have clinched a berth (and with a couple days before their next game), now is as good a time as any for a little reflection.
Phil has said a few times that the first time he saw this bunch play, he wondered if the could win 30 games. He's revised that estimate upwards as the season has gone along. Me? I've done the opposite. Before the season, I said they'd win 46, then and get bounced in the first round. At midseason, when they were on a nice lil' winnin' streak, I bumped up those estimates to around 47 or 48. Then the Lakers went into the tank and I wondered if they'd even finish .500, forcing me to go back and delete the earlier predictions from the site. Now 45 wins is a strong possibility, and the playoff spot is locked up. Considering the roster has less experience than a roomful of computer geeks at freshman orientation, it's hard to complain about those results. Now the younger guys will get a taste of the postseason, which will be valuable for those who are still around when the rebuilding is complete.
Even better, it looks like Kwame Brown has the potential to be a consistent, solid NBA center, L.O. may have seen the triangle light bulb go off in his head, and best of all, Kobe and Phil haven't spent the year keying each other's car. There may just be a workable nucleus in LA after all, a nice change from January when many felt the best plan was keep Kobe and ship out everyone not named Bynum ASAP.
So what do you think? Success or not? Is it championships or bust (the George Steinbrenner approach to fandom)? Will you take what you can get?
Obviously, fans want the whole enchilada. But putting aside the chest puffing, "NOTHING BUT A CHAMPIONSHIP IS ACCEPTABLE!" rhetoric for a moment, I would have to say that even if they're bounced in the first round, this was a successful season for the purple and gold. Not enough to rest on their laurels, but successful nonetheless.
As always, justify your answer.
BK